---
title: "Net Interest Margin: Community Bank Benchmarks and Trends"
description: "Net interest margin benchmarks for community banks in 2025: what is typical, what examiners flag, and how deposit repricing reshaped NIM."
canonical_url: https://www.bankregreports.com/blog/how-to-calculate-nim-call-report-data/
source: BankRegReports
published: "2026-10-02"
updated: "2026-10-28"
---

The median net interest margin for community banks in the $1B–$10B asset range sat at roughly 3.3–3.5% entering 2025 and rose to about 3.7% by June 30, 2026, above its late-2022 peak. If your NIM has compressed 30 to 50 basis points from its high and you are trying to explain it to the board, you are not alone. But where you sit within that range matters more than the number in isolation, and the trajectory matters more than the current quarter.

Understanding NIM means understanding how your institution's earning asset mix and funding cost structure interact, and then knowing how that profile compares to your actual peer group, not a national average that includes banks twice your size.


<figure>
  <img src="/static/blog/figures/distribution_nim.svg" alt="Distribution of net interest margins across U.S. banks" loading="lazy">
  <figcaption>Net interest margins across the U.S. banking industry.</figcaption>
</figure>

## What Does Net Interest Margin Tell Examiners and the Board?

NIM measures annualized net interest income as a percentage of average earning assets. It is the single most important driver of pre-provision profitability for most community banks, and it sits at the center of the CAMELS "E" (Earnings) component evaluation. These figures come from the quarterly Call Report, whose official source is the [FFIEC](https://www.ffiec.gov). When NIM compresses significantly relative to peers, examiners will want to understand whether the cause is structural (asset sensitivity mismatch, high-cost deposit mix, heavy reliance on brokered funds) or cyclical (lag in loan repricing as rates normalized).

The board wants to see NIM trend alongside ROA, because a bank can temporarily hold up earnings through fee income or expense cuts, but sustained NIM compression eventually shows up in profitability. Management tracks NIM monthly or quarterly against budget, against the prior year, and against a peer group. These are not the same question, and the answers sometimes point in different directions.

For exam purposes, examiners are less concerned with an absolute NIM level than with whether management understands why NIM is where it is and whether the ALCO process is actively managing the drivers. A bank at 3.1% NIM with a clear rate sensitivity strategy and documented deposit retention plan looks very different in an exam than a bank at 3.1% with no model and no strategy.

![Community Bank NIM vs. Large Banks, Q2 2026](figures/how-to-calculate-nim-call-report-data-1.svg)

## The Rate Cycle Story: 2022–2025

The 2022–2023 rate hiking cycle produced an unusual NIM pattern for community banks. In the initial lift-off phase (roughly mid-2022 through early 2023) NIM expanded as loan yields repriced upward faster than deposit costs. Community banks with floating-rate loan books and sticky core deposit bases saw some of the best NIM readings in a decade.

The compression that followed was equally predictable in hindsight. Deposit betas (the percentage of Fed funds rate increases passed through to depositors) ran at 35–55% cumulatively for community banks over the full cycle, but with a lag of roughly two quarters. By the time the Fed paused in mid-2023, many community banks were still watching their [cost of funds](/blog/deposit-beta-and-cost-of-funds/) climb. Interest-bearing deposit costs that were 30–50 basis points in 2021 moved to 200–250 basis points or higher by late 2023, while loan yields had largely stabilized.

That lag dynamic, asset repricing outrunning liability repricing on the way up, then the reverse, is the mechanical explanation for why NIM peaked and then compressed even as short-term rates remained elevated. Banks with higher concentrations of fixed-rate mortgage loans and longer-term investment securities experienced more compression than those with commercial loan books that repriced quickly. The outlook entering 2025 was a gradual stabilization, with NIM expected to settle in the 3.25–3.45% range for the median community bank; instead, the $1B–$10B median rose to about 3.7% by June 30, 2026 as deposit costs eased.


## Where Your NIM Should Actually Land

Benchmarks only matter if they reflect your actual peer group. A $400M mutual savings bank in rural New England has a structurally different NIM profile than a $4B commercial bank in a Sun Belt metro, and comparing them as if they were peers produces misleading conclusions.

That said, some reference points hold across most community bank segments. A NIM above about 4.1% (the 75th percentile for $1B–$10B banks at June 30, 2026) generally indicates either a high-yield loan book (more credit risk exposure), strong core deposit franchise (lower cost of funds), or both. A NIM below 3.0% warrants a conversation about earning asset mix: whether the bank is over-invested in lower-yielding securities, holding significant non-earning assets, or paying above-market deposit rates to retain funding.

The [efficiency ratio](/glossary/efficiency-ratio/) context matters here. A bank running a 3.1% NIM with a 58% efficiency ratio may be in fine shape. A bank at 3.1% NIM with a 72% efficiency ratio has a structural earnings problem that will pressure capital if it persists. Examiners will look at these together, not in isolation.

For ALCO purposes, the metrics that decompose NIM into components you can act on are yield on loans, yield on investments, cost of interest-bearing deposits, and cost of borrowings. Moving NIM means moving one or more of these, and each one responds to different levers. Yield on loans responds to underwriting standards, loan mix, and origination rates. Cost of deposits responds to pricing strategy, product mix, and competitive dynamics in your market. Knowing which component is driving your NIM variance quarter-to-quarter is the minimum standard for an effective ALCO discussion.

## The Denominator Question That Trips Up Peer Comparisons

One persistent source of confusion in NIM peer comparisons is what goes in the denominator. The FFIEC Uniform Bank Performance Report methodology, which is the standard for published peer comparisons, uses average earning assets from Call Report Schedule RC-K, not total average assets. Average earning assets excludes cash, premises, other real estate, and goodwill.

If your internal model uses total average assets as the denominator, your NIM will look lower than your [UBPR](/blog/how-to-read-ubpr-report/) peer comparison by anywhere from 10 to 40 basis points depending on how much non-earning asset exposure you carry. That gap has caused more than a few uncomfortable moments when a banker presents an internal NIM figure that looks materially different from the regulator's calculation.

For tax-equivalent NIM, common in banks with meaningful municipal bond portfolios, the standard adjustment grosses up tax-exempt interest income at the federal corporate tax rate (21% post-2017). This adjustment typically adds 5 to 15 basis points for community banks with moderate muni exposure, and more for institutions that have leaned heavily into the muni market for yield.

The NIM BankRegReports shows is the UBPR's measure (UBPRE680): tax-equivalent net interest income for the latest quarter, annualized, divided by average earning assets from Schedule RC-K. The FDIC's figure (NIMY in BankFind and the Quarterly Banking Profile) uses year-to-date net interest income without the tax-equivalent adjustment, divided by the mean of quarter-end earning assets, so ours usually runs a few basis points below the FDIC's for the same bank and quarter.

The [BankRegReports platform](https://www.bankregreports.com) standardizes these methodology decisions across all institutions using the same UBPR-consistent approach, which means a peer comparison you pull from the platform will match what your regulator sees rather than producing a number you have to reconcile in the exam.

## What to Watch After the Hiking Cycle

Three dynamics shape community bank NIM as rates come down from the 2023 peak. First, the pace and magnitude of Fed rate cuts. Banks that positioned for asset sensitivity through floating-rate commercial loans will see yield compression as rates decline, while those with fixed-rate portfolios locked in at 2023–2024 origination rates may see relative stability or even mild expansion. Second, deposit cost stickiness. Many community banks repriced CDs at 4.5–5.0% during the competitive deposit environment of 2023–2024. As those CDs mature and reprice lower, cost of funds should decline, but the pace depends on how aggressively competitors continue to offer promotional rates. Third, loan demand. If commercial loan origination softens, banks will struggle to replace maturing lower-rate loans with higher-yielding new production, creating a headwind to asset yield even as funding costs improve.

The institutions that will come through this environment with NIM at or above peer medians are generally those that maintained pricing discipline on deposits rather than chasing every CD rate escalation, built commercial relationships with meaningful floating-rate exposure, and avoided loading up on long-duration fixed-rate securities at the 2021–2022 lows.

For your next ALCO package, the most useful benchmark exercise is comparing your NIM trend to your actual peer group, banks in the same asset tier, charter class, and geographic market, rather than industry-wide averages. You can pull that peer comparison directly from the [BankRegReports platform](https://www.bankregreports.com), filter to your specific peer set, and export the NIM trend alongside cost of funds and yield on loans into your existing ALCO template.

The banks that face examiner questions on NIM are not primarily those with low NIMs; they are the ones that cannot demonstrate a clear understanding of why their NIM is where it is and what they are doing about it.

---

The benchmarks and peer data referenced in this post are available through the [BankRegReports platform](https://www.bankregreports.com), no data engineering required. Search any FDIC-insured bank, pull peer group comparisons, and, on the Pro plan, export to Excel for your ALCO package or board presentation.

## About this document

This is the markdown twin of the page named in `canonical_url` above. Source filings are public record; the cleaning, normalization, cross-source linkage, and derived metrics are BankRegReports' own. Attribute with a link to the canonical URL.

Markdown twins are published for editorial content only. Institution data pages do not have them. For data at scale use the API, which is documented at https://www.bankregreports.com/api/ and specified at https://www.bankregreports.com/openapi.json. It returns typed JSON with explicit units and periods, and one call replaces hundreds of page fetches.


## Sitemap

- [Glossary](https://www.bankregreports.com/glossary/): every metric, with formula and thresholds
- [Blog](https://www.bankregreports.com/blog/): analysis and explainers
- [API documentation](https://www.bankregreports.com/api/): the programmatic way to get this data
- [XML sitemap](https://www.bankregreports.com/sitemap.xml): the complete crawlable index
