Skip to main content

Profitability ranking · New York · Call report data as of September 30, 2026

New York Banks with Highest Return on Assets (ROA)

Bessemer Trust Company, N.A. has the highest ROA of the 98 ranked banks headquartered in New York, at 3.88% as of September 30, 2026. The median among the 98 ranked New York banks is 0.99%, against 1.30% for all US banks. That top value sits far outside the middle half of ranked banks (0.52% to 1.36%). Values this extreme usually reflect an unusual business model, such as a credit card lender or another specialty lender, or a one-time item in the quarter, rather than typical performance, so the median is the better benchmark.

This list ranks New York banks by return on assets. For the largest banks headquartered in New York, see largest banks in New York.

No. 1 in New York
Bessemer Trust Company
Its ROA
3.88%
New York median
0.99%
Banks ranked
98

Ranked among banks headquartered in New York, numbered 1 to 98 within the state from the same population as the national list. Browse every bank in the New York bank directory.

Top 98 New York banks by return on assets

Highest first. Select a column heading to sort. The gap column shows each bank's distance from the New York median of 0.99%. Missing values show as a dash and sort last.

New York Banks with Highest Return on Assets (ROA), Q3 2026: rank, bank, state, ROA, distance from the median and total assets.
1 Bessemer Trust Company, N.A. New York, NY NY 3.88% +2.89 pts $4.90B $1B to $10B
2 Bank of Millbrook Millbrook, NY NY 2.25% +1.25 pts $336.0M $100M to $1B
3 The First National Bank of Dryden Dryden, NY NY 2.12% +1.13 pts $207.2M $100M to $1B
4 Jeff Bank, N.A. Jeffersonville, NY NY 2.09% +1.09 pts $678.5M $100M to $1B
5 Northeast Community Bank White Plains, NY NY 2.08% +1.08 pts $2.21B $1B to $10B
6 First Federal Savings of Middletown Middletown, NY NY 2.07% +1.08 pts $189.9M $100M to $1B
7 Esquire Bank, N.A. Jericho, NY NY 1.94% +0.95 pts $4.80B $1B to $10B
8 Chemung Canal Trust Company, N.A. Elmira, NY NY 1.88% +0.88 pts $2.85B $1B to $10B
9 Amerasia Bank Flushing, NY NY 1.86% +0.87 pts $1.08B $1B to $10B
10 Watertown Savings Bank Watertown, NY NY 1.83% +0.83 pts $983.0M $100M to $1B
11 Ponce Bank, N.A. Bronx, NY NY 1.82% +0.83 pts $3.67B $1B to $10B
12 Orange Bank & Trust Company Middletown, NY NY 1.80% +0.81 pts $2.73B $1B to $10B
13 Bank of Holland Holland, NY NY 1.69% +0.69 pts $256.4M $100M to $1B
14 Alden State Bank Alden, NY NY 1.66% +0.67 pts $464.0M $100M to $1B
15 Bank of Greene Catskill, NY NY 1.65% +0.66 pts $3.24B $1B to $10B
16 Spring Bank Bronx, NY NY 1.64% +0.65 pts $628.4M $100M to $1B
17 The Bank of New York Mellon New York, NY NY 1.58% +0.58 pts $392.89B $100B and over
18 Amalgamated Bank New York, NY NY 1.56% +0.57 pts $9.73B $1B to $10B
19 Mizuho Bank (USA) New York, NY NY 1.55% +0.56 pts $1.75B $1B to $10B
20 Metropolitan Commercial Bank New York, NY NY 1.48% +0.49 pts $9.47B $1B to $10B
21 Bank of Utica Utica, NY NY 1.46% +0.47 pts $1.52B $1B to $10B
22 Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company Buffalo, NY NY 1.44% +0.44 pts $219.99B $100B and over
23 Tompkins Bank & Trust Ithaca, NY NY 1.42% +0.43 pts $8.97B $1B to $10B
24 Newbank Flushing, NY NY 1.40% +0.40 pts $639.0M $100M to $1B
25 Five Star Bank Rochester, NY NY 1.37% +0.38 pts $6.47B $1B to $10B
26 Massena Savings and Loan Massena, NY NY 1.32% +0.33 pts $202.9M $100M to $1B
27 The Adirondack Trust Company Saratoga Springs, NY NY 1.32% +0.32 pts $1.75B $1B to $10B
28 NBT Bank, N.A. Norwich, NY NY 1.31% +0.31 pts $16.27B $10B to $100B
29 Interaudi Bank New York, NY NY 1.30% +0.31 pts $2.67B $1B to $10B
30 Walden Savings Bank Montgomery, NY NY 1.27% +0.28 pts $1.04B $1B to $10B
31 The Lyons National Bank Lyons, NY NY 1.27% +0.27 pts $2.21B $1B to $10B
32 The First National Bank of Groton Groton, NY NY 1.26% +0.26 pts $203.6M $100M to $1B
33 Genesee Regional Bank Rochester, NY NY 1.26% +0.26 pts $1.31B $1B to $10B
34 Lake Shore Bank Dunkirk, NY NY 1.23% +0.24 pts $733.5M $100M to $1B
35 The Putnam County National Bank of Carmel Carmel, NY NY 1.23% +0.23 pts $186.8M $100M to $1B
36 Fulton Savings Bank Fulton, NY NY 1.20% +0.21 pts $486.4M $100M to $1B
37 Community Bank, N.A. Canton, NY NY 1.19% +0.20 pts $17.47B $10B to $100B
38 Dime Commercial Bank Bridgehampton, NY NY 1.17% +0.18 pts $15.54B $10B to $100B
39 Woori America Bank New York, NY NY 1.17% +0.18 pts $4.35B $1B to $10B
40 The Canandaigua National Bank and Trust Company Canandaigua, NY NY 1.17% +0.17 pts $5.53B $1B to $10B
41 Carthage Savings and Loan, N.A. Carthage, NY NY 1.15% +0.16 pts $310.8M $100M to $1B
42 Morgan Stanley Private Bank, N.A. Purchase, NY NY 1.12% +0.12 pts $258.63B $100B and over
43 Popular Bank New York, NY NY 1.10% +0.10 pts $15.14B $10B to $100B
44 TrustCo Bank Glenville, NY NY 1.06% +0.06 pts $6.49B $1B to $10B
45 Goldman Sachs Bank USA New York, NY NY 1.04% +0.04 pts $789.72B $100B and over
46 Tioga State Bank, N.A. Spencer, NY NY 1.03% +0.04 pts $628.7M $100M to $1B
47 Habib American Bank New York, NY NY 1.03% +0.03 pts $3.03B $1B to $10B
48 The North Country Savings Bank Canton, NY NY 1.02% +0.03 pts $380.3M $100M to $1B
49 American Community Bank Glen Cove, NY NY 1.00% +0.01 pts $314.7M $100M to $1B
50 Champlain National Bank Elizabethtown, NY NY 0.99% -0.01 pts $502.8M $100M to $1B
51 Cayuga Lake National Bank Union Springs, NY NY 0.99% -0.01 pts $270.8M $100M to $1B
52 Maspeth Federal Savings and Loan Association Maspeth, NY NY 0.97% -0.02 pts $2.22B $1B to $10B
53 Grasshopper Bank, N.A. New York, NY NY 0.96% -0.04 pts $1.58B $1B to $10B
54 First National Bank of Scotia Scotia, NY NY 0.92% -0.07 pts $723.9M $100M to $1B
55 Rhinebeck Bank Rhinebeck, NY NY 0.92% -0.08 pts $1.51B $1B to $10B
56 Alpine Capital Bank New York, NY NY 0.89% -0.10 pts $239.6M $100M to $1B
57 Bank of Richmondville Cobleskill, NY NY 0.87% -0.12 pts $191.4M $100M to $1B
58 Maple City Savings Bank, FSB Hornell, NY NY 0.86% -0.13 pts $121.0M $100M to $1B
59 The Delaware National Bank of Delhi Delhi, NY NY 0.85% -0.15 pts $381.5M $100M to $1B
60 Empire State Bank Staten Island, NY NY 0.83% -0.17 pts $596.3M $100M to $1B
61 Safra National Bank of New York New York, NY NY 0.82% -0.18 pts $13.53B $10B to $100B
62 Cattaraugus County Bank Little Valley, NY NY 0.81% -0.18 pts $370.2M $100M to $1B
63 Pathfinder Bank Oswego, NY NY 0.79% -0.20 pts $1.48B $1B to $10B
64 Quontic Bank Astoria, NY NY 0.79% -0.21 pts $886.6M $100M to $1B
65 Hanover Community Bank Garden City Park, NY NY 0.78% -0.21 pts $2.44B $1B to $10B
66 Israel Discount Bank of New York New York, NY NY 0.78% -0.22 pts $14.54B $10B to $100B
67 Wallkill Valley Federal Savings and Loan Association Wallkill, NY NY 0.73% -0.26 pts $481.2M $100M to $1B
68 Alma Bank Astoria, NY NY 0.72% -0.28 pts $1.61B $1B to $10B
69 Solvay Bank Solvay, NY NY 0.64% -0.35 pts $1.23B $1B to $10B
70 Apple Bank New York, NY NY 0.63% -0.36 pts $19.96B $10B to $100B
71 Ulster Savings Bank Kingston, NY NY 0.59% -0.40 pts $1.38B $1B to $10B
72 Savannah Bank, N.A. Savannah, NY NY 0.54% -0.45 pts $180.2M $100M to $1B
73 Shinhan Bank America New York, NY NY 0.54% -0.46 pts $2.17B $1B to $10B
74 Ridgewood Savings Bank Ridgewood, NY NY 0.51% -0.48 pts $7.57B $1B to $10B
75 The Berkshire Bank New York, NY NY 0.50% -0.49 pts $483.7M $100M to $1B
76 Abacus Federal Savings Bank New York, NY NY 0.50% -0.50 pts $325.0M $100M to $1B
77 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (USA), N.A. New York, NY NY 0.47% -0.52 pts $2.79B $1B to $10B
78 Arrow Bank N.A. Glens Falls, NY NY 0.42% -0.57 pts $5.52B $1B to $10B
79 Eastbank, N.A. New York, NY NY 0.39% -0.61 pts $164.1M $100M to $1B
80 Geddes Federal Savings and Loan Association Syracuse, NY NY 0.35% -0.64 pts $668.2M $100M to $1B
81 Cross County Savings Bank Middle Village, NY NY 0.35% -0.64 pts $530.3M $100M to $1B
82 The Upstate National Bank Ogdensburg, NY NY 0.34% -0.66 pts $289.3M $100M to $1B
83 Sawyer Savings Bank Saugerties, NY NY 0.32% -0.67 pts $280.5M $100M to $1B
84 Ballston Spa National Bank Ballston Spa, NY NY 0.32% -0.67 pts $1.38B $1B to $10B
85 Rondout Savings Bank Kingston, NY NY 0.30% -0.70 pts $514.6M $100M to $1B
86 First Central Savings Bank Glen Cove, NY NY 0.24% -0.76 pts $1.09B $1B to $10B
87 Seneca Savings Bank, N.A. Baldwinsville, NY NY 0.22% -0.77 pts $315.6M $100M to $1B
88 Global Bank New York, NY NY 0.21% -0.79 pts $317.0M $100M to $1B
89 Pioneer Bank, N.A. Albany, NY NY 0.08% -0.91 pts $2.57B $1B to $10B
90 Flagstar Bank, N.A. Hicksville, NY NY 0.05% -0.94 pts $87.41B $10B to $100B
91 United Orient Bank New York, NY NY 0.02% -0.97 pts $103.7M $100M to $1B
92 BTG Pactual Bank, N.A. New York, NY NY -0.23% -1.22 pts $1.22B $1B to $10B
93 Community Federal Savings Bank Woodhaven, NY NY -0.43% -1.43 pts $845.3M $100M to $1B
94 Modern Bank, N.A. New York, NY NY -0.62% -1.61 pts $650.0M $100M to $1B
95 Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas New York, NY NY -0.95% -1.94 pts $42.45B $10B to $100B
96 Carver Federal Savings Bank New York, NY NY -1.06% -2.06 pts $662.8M $100M to $1B
97 Piermont Bank New York, NY NY -1.80% -2.80 pts $505.8M $100M to $1B
98 Gouverneur Savings and Loan Association Gouverneur, NY NY -6.03% -7.02 pts $191.8M $100M to $1B

Screen every bank in New York by ROA and filter by size, capital and credit in the screener. Free account, no card. Open the screener →

Definition and formula

Return on assets (ROA) is a bank's annualized net income divided by its average total assets, expressed as a percentage. It shows how much profit the bank earns on each dollar of its balance sheet, whatever its size or capital structure.

ROA = Annualized Net Income / Average Total Assets

The glossary entry for Return on Assets explains each term, the call report items behind it and a worked example.

Which banks are ranked

This list ranks the 98 banks headquartered in New York that meet every rule below, using each bank's latest FFIEC call report (data as of September 30, 2026).

  • Banks with at least $100M in total assets, so a ratio on a very small balance sheet cannot lead the list.
  • Lending institutions only: charters with loans under 5% of assets, mostly trust and custody banks, are not ranked.
  • Values below -10% or above 10% are treated as implausible for this ratio and are not ranked.
  • Charters the regulator has closed, merged or converted are excluded.
  • Each bank charter ranks on its own; holding companies are not combined.

Banks whose quarter was driven by the stock market are left off this list. Since 2018, gains and losses on stocks a bank holds count as income, and at about two dozen banks those paper gains or losses were at least half of pre-tax income for the quarter, which can lift return on assets several-fold (one bank's 7.63% falls to about 2% without them). Each such bank's own page shows its filed figures and explains the gap.

What moves ROA

ROA rises with a wider net interest margin, more fee income or lower operating costs, and falls when the bank has to add to its allowance for credit losses. One-time items move it too: a securities gain or a reserve release can lift a single quarter. Subchapter S banks pay no income tax at the bank level, so their after-tax ROA runs higher than a taxed bank's with the same pre-tax earnings.

Frequently asked questions

Which bank in New York has the highest ROA?

Bessemer Trust Company, N.A. has the highest ROA of the 98 ranked banks headquartered in New York, at 3.88% as of September 30, 2026, according to its FFIEC call report. Bank of Millbrook ranks second at 2.25%. The median is 0.99%.

What is the median ROA among ranked US banks?

As of Q3 2026, ROA for the middle half of the 3,622 ranked US banks ran from 0.89% to 1.72%, and the median was 1.30%. Analysts' reference bands run from ≥ 1.50% (strong) to < 0.50% (concern). Compare a bank with peers of the same size and business model rather than with the top of this list. See the Return on Assets reference bands.

How is ROA calculated?

ROA = Annualized Net Income / Average Total Assets. Net income is the bottom line of the income statement, Call Report Schedule RI, item 14. See the Return on Assets glossary entry.

The same ranking in other states

Other New York rankings

More profitability rankings

Go past the leaderboard: open any bank for its full financials, 26-year trends, and peer percentiles. Free, no card required.

Start free, no card required

Source: FFIEC call reports for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, refreshed as each quarter's filings are processed. See data updates for the current freshness window. Next update: Q4 2026 Call Reports are due February 1, 2027; we expect them on the platform by mid-February 2027.

Go deeper: ROA vs. ROE for Banks: Profitability Ratios Explained · All bank rankings · Bank metrics glossary · List of all US banks