Skip to main content

Profitability ranking · Ohio · Call report data as of September 30, 2026

Ohio Banks with Highest Return on Assets (ROA)

Sutton Bank has the highest ROA of the 130 ranked banks headquartered in Ohio, at 4.56% as of September 30, 2026. The median among the 130 ranked Ohio banks is 1.18%, against 1.30% for all US banks. That top value sits far outside the middle half of ranked banks (0.69% to 1.47%). Values this extreme usually reflect an unusual business model, such as a credit card lender or another specialty lender, or a one-time item in the quarter, rather than typical performance, so the median is the better benchmark.

This list ranks Ohio banks by return on assets. For the largest banks headquartered in Ohio, see largest banks in Ohio.

No. 1 in Ohio
Sutton Bank
Its ROA
4.56%
Ohio median
1.18%
Banks ranked
130

Ranked among banks headquartered in Ohio, numbered 1 to 100 within the state from the same population as the national list. Browse every bank in the Ohio bank directory.

Top 100 Ohio banks by return on assets

Highest first. Select a column heading to sort. The gap column shows each bank's distance from the Ohio median of 1.18%. Missing values show as a dash and sort last.

Ohio Banks with Highest Return on Assets (ROA), Q3 2026: rank, bank, state, ROA, distance from the median and total assets.
1 Sutton Bank Attica, OH OH 4.56% +3.38 pts $1.96B $1B to $10B
2 Buckeye State Bank Powell, OH OH 4.14% +2.96 pts $598.6M $100M to $1B
3 The St. Henry Bank Saint Henry, OH OH 3.22% +2.05 pts $422.3M $100M to $1B
4 First Bank of Ohio Tiffin, OH OH 2.81% +1.63 pts $276.7M $100M to $1B
5 Spring Valley Bank Wyoming, OH OH 2.71% +1.54 pts $108.2M $100M to $1B
6 SSB Community Bank Strasburg, OH OH 2.70% +1.52 pts $321.8M $100M to $1B
7 The Citizens National Bank of Bluffton Bluffton, OH OH 2.59% +1.41 pts $1.09B $1B to $10B
8 The National Bank of Adams County of West Union West Union, OH OH 2.33% +1.15 pts $116.0M $100M to $1B
9 The Home Loan Savings Bank Coshocton, OH OH 2.29% +1.11 pts $388.8M $100M to $1B
10 Settlers Bank Marietta, OH OH 2.10% +0.92 pts $141.6M $100M to $1B
11 The Hamler State Bank Hamler, OH OH 1.98% +0.80 pts $125.3M $100M to $1B
12 The Park National Bank Newark, OH OH 1.95% +0.77 pts $12.60B $10B to $100B
13 First Federal Community Bank, N.A. Dover, OH OH 1.95% +0.77 pts $1.03B $1B to $10B
14 Greenville National Bank Greenville, OH OH 1.94% +0.76 pts $646.5M $100M to $1B
15 Farmers & Merchants Bank Miamisburg, OH OH 1.85% +0.67 pts $371.3M $100M to $1B
16 The Fahey Banking Company Marion, OH OH 1.81% +0.64 pts $389.9M $100M to $1B
17 Signature Bank, N.A. Toledo, OH OH 1.69% +0.52 pts $1.37B $1B to $10B
18 Main Street Bank Corp. Wooster, OH OH 1.69% +0.51 pts $1.61B $1B to $10B
19 The Fort Jennings State Bank Fort Jennings, OH OH 1.69% +0.51 pts $290.0M $100M to $1B
20 The Citizens Bank Company Beverly, OH OH 1.66% +0.49 pts $337.3M $100M to $1B
21 The Old Fort Banking Company Old Fort, OH OH 1.66% +0.48 pts $830.8M $100M to $1B
22 Union Savings Bank Cincinnati, OH OH 1.65% +0.48 pts $4.07B $1B to $10B
23 Guardian Savings Bank West Chester, OH OH 1.64% +0.47 pts $1.40B $1B to $10B
24 The Peoples Bank Co. Coldwater, OH OH 1.63% +0.46 pts $858.7M $100M to $1B
25 Minster Bank Minster, OH OH 1.63% +0.46 pts $842.3M $100M to $1B
26 First Financial Bank Cincinnati, OH OH 1.61% +0.44 pts $22.22B $10B to $100B
27 The Farmers State Bank New Madison, OH OH 1.59% +0.41 pts $319.2M $100M to $1B
28 Civista Bank Sandusky, OH OH 1.57% +0.40 pts $4.30B $1B to $10B
29 The Union Bank Company Columbus Grove, OH OH 1.55% +0.38 pts $1.45B $1B to $10B
30 The Hocking Valley Bank Athens, OH OH 1.54% +0.37 pts $354.9M $100M to $1B
31 The Commercial and Savings Bank of Millersburg, Ohio Millersburg, OH OH 1.51% +0.34 pts $1.31B $1B to $10B
32 Peoples Bank Marietta, OH OH 1.50% +0.32 pts $9.64B $1B to $10B
33 First National Bank in New Bremen New Bremen, OH OH 1.48% +0.31 pts $470.6M $100M to $1B
34 Riverhills Bank Milford, OH OH 1.43% +0.25 pts $330.8M $100M to $1B
35 The Community Bank Zanesville, OH OH 1.42% +0.24 pts $683.7M $100M to $1B
36 The Baltic State Bank Baltic, OH OH 1.42% +0.24 pts $126.6M $100M to $1B
37 Osgood Bank Osgood, OH OH 1.41% +0.24 pts $481.9M $100M to $1B
38 Waterford Bank, N.A. Toledo, OH OH 1.39% +0.22 pts $1.84B $1B to $10B
39 LCNB National Bank Lebanon, OH OH 1.39% +0.22 pts $2.28B $1B to $10B
40 KeyBank N.A. Cleveland, OH OH 1.39% +0.21 pts $190.15B $100B and over
41 First Federal Community Bank of Bucyrus Bucyrus, OH OH 1.38% +0.21 pts $390.8M $100M to $1B
42 New Carlisle Federal Savings Bank New Carlisle, OH OH 1.36% +0.18 pts $332.5M $100M to $1B
43 The Croghan Colonial Bank Fremont, OH OH 1.35% +0.17 pts $1.41B $1B to $10B
44 The First National Bank of Sycamore Sycamore, OH OH 1.34% +0.17 pts $234.7M $100M to $1B
45 The Farmers & Merchants State Bank Archbold, OH OH 1.34% +0.16 pts $3.58B $1B to $10B
46 Community Savings Caldwell, OH OH 1.33% +0.16 pts $283.9M $100M to $1B
47 The Richwood Banking Company, Inc. Richwood, OH OH 1.33% +0.16 pts $1.28B $1B to $10B
48 Cfbank N.A. Columbus, OH OH 1.33% +0.15 pts $2.21B $1B to $10B
49 National Cooperative Bank, N.A. Hillsboro, OH OH 1.32% +0.14 pts $4.25B $1B to $10B
50 Portage Community Bank Ravenna, OH OH 1.31% +0.14 pts $561.6M $100M to $1B
51 Miami Savings Bank Miamitown, OH OH 1.31% +0.14 pts $150.9M $100M to $1B
52 The First National Bank of McConnelsville McConnelsville, OH OH 1.31% +0.14 pts $195.2M $100M to $1B
53 U.S. Bank N.A. Cincinnati, OH OH 1.30% +0.12 pts $685.33B $100B and over
54 North Valley Bank Zanesville, OH OH 1.27% +0.10 pts $433.8M $100M to $1B
55 JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. Columbus, OH OH 1.27% +0.09 pts $4.17T $100B and over
56 Merchants National Bank Hillsboro, OH OH 1.26% +0.08 pts $1.27B $1B to $10B
57 Fifth Third Bank, N.A. Cincinnati, OH OH 1.25% +0.07 pts $300.34B $100B and over
58 The Citizens National Bank of McConnelsville McConnelsville, OH OH 1.24% +0.06 pts $101.4M $100M to $1B
59 Vinton County National Bank McArthur, OH OH 1.24% +0.06 pts $1.62B $1B to $10B
60 The Killbuck Savings Bank Company Killbuck, OH OH 1.22% +0.04 pts $965.2M $100M to $1B
61 The North Side Bank and Trust Company Cincinnati, OH OH 1.20% +0.02 pts $1.18B $1B to $10B
62 Woodsfield Savings Bank Woodsfield, OH OH 1.20% +0.02 pts $127.4M $100M to $1B
63 Farmers State Bank West Salem, OH OH 1.20% +0.02 pts $192.7M $100M to $1B
64 Home Federal Savings and Loan Association of Niles Ohio Niles, OH OH 1.19% +0.01 pts $156.3M $100M to $1B
65 The Citizens National Bank of Woodsfield Woodsfield, OH OH 1.19% +0.01 pts $157.2M $100M to $1B
66 Home Savings and Loan Company of Kenton, Ohio, the dba HSLC Kenton, OH OH 1.16% -0.01 pts $245.0M $100M to $1B
67 The Harrison Building and Loan Association Harrison, OH OH 1.13% -0.05 pts $266.8M $100M to $1B
68 The Antwerp Exchange Bank Company Antwerp, OH OH 1.12% -0.05 pts $164.9M $100M to $1B
69 The Huntington National Bank Columbus, OH OH 1.12% -0.06 pts $287.08B $100B and over
70 First State Bank Winchester, OH OH 1.12% -0.06 pts $1.22B $1B to $10B
71 Ohio State Bank Bexley, OH OH 1.09% -0.09 pts $500.3M $100M to $1B
72 The First National Bank of Pandora Pandora, OH OH 1.05% -0.13 pts $304.8M $100M to $1B
73 The Savings Bank Circleville, OH OH 1.04% -0.14 pts $521.0M $100M to $1B
74 The Apple Creek Banking Company Apple Creek, OH OH 1.03% -0.15 pts $280.1M $100M to $1B
75 The Corn City State Bank Deshler, OH OH 1.03% -0.15 pts $104.9M $100M to $1B
76 The Farmers and Merchants Bank Caldwell, OH OH 1.02% -0.16 pts $135.7M $100M to $1B
77 The State Bank and Trust Company Defiance, OH OH 1.02% -0.16 pts $1.60B $1B to $10B
78 Unified Bank Martins Ferry, OH OH 1.01% -0.17 pts $893.2M $100M to $1B
79 The Cincinnatus Savings and Loan Company Cheviot, OH OH 0.99% -0.19 pts $189.6M $100M to $1B
80 The Genoa Banking Company Genoa, OH OH 0.97% -0.20 pts $767.2M $100M to $1B
81 The Farmers Bank and Savings Company Pomeroy, OH OH 0.97% -0.21 pts $469.1M $100M to $1B
82 Consumers National Bank Minerva, OH OH 0.96% -0.21 pts $1.29B $1B to $10B
83 The Andover Bank Andover, OH OH 0.94% -0.24 pts $589.0M $100M to $1B
84 Peoples State Bank New Lexington, OH OH 0.93% -0.24 pts $303.8M $100M to $1B
85 The First National Bank of Waverly Waverly, OH OH 0.90% -0.27 pts $202.4M $100M to $1B
86 The Peoples Savings Bank Urbana, OH OH 0.86% -0.31 pts $194.3M $100M to $1B
87 Kingston National Bank Kingston, OH OH 0.85% -0.33 pts $582.9M $100M to $1B
88 The Sherwood State Bank Sherwood, OH OH 0.84% -0.33 pts $109.5M $100M to $1B
89 Mercer Savings Bank Celina, OH OH 0.84% -0.34 pts $176.4M $100M to $1B
90 The First National Bank of Bellevue Bellevue, OH OH 0.84% -0.34 pts $319.4M $100M to $1B
91 The Ohio Valley Bank Company Gallipolis, OH OH 0.82% -0.36 pts $1.64B $1B to $10B
92 The Bank of Magnolia Company Magnolia, OH OH 0.82% -0.36 pts $108.4M $100M to $1B
93 The Farmers National Bank of Canfield Canfield, OH OH 0.81% -0.37 pts $7.10B $1B to $10B
94 The Peoples Savings and Loan Company West Liberty, OH OH 0.80% -0.37 pts $109.9M $100M to $1B
95 Buckeye Community Bank Elyria, OH OH 0.79% -0.39 pts $248.9M $100M to $1B
96 The First National Bank of Dennison, Ohio Dennison, OH OH 0.78% -0.39 pts $272.5M $100M to $1B
97 Mechanics Bank Mansfield, OH OH 0.71% -0.46 pts $919.6M $100M to $1B
98 The Wilmington Savings Bank Wilmington, OH OH 0.68% -0.49 pts $268.0M $100M to $1B
99 Independence Bank Independence, OH OH 0.66% -0.51 pts $183.9M $100M to $1B
100 Valley Central Bank Liberty Township, OH OH 0.64% -0.53 pts $185.6M $100M to $1B

Screen every bank in Ohio by ROA and filter by size, capital and credit in the screener. Free account, no card. Open the screener →

Definition and formula

Return on assets (ROA) is a bank's annualized net income divided by its average total assets, expressed as a percentage. It shows how much profit the bank earns on each dollar of its balance sheet, whatever its size or capital structure.

ROA = Annualized Net Income / Average Total Assets

The glossary entry for Return on Assets explains each term, the call report items behind it and a worked example.

Which banks are ranked

This list ranks the 130 banks headquartered in Ohio that meet every rule below, using each bank's latest FFIEC call report (data as of September 30, 2026).

  • Banks with at least $100M in total assets, so a ratio on a very small balance sheet cannot lead the list.
  • Lending institutions only: charters with loans under 5% of assets, mostly trust and custody banks, are not ranked.
  • Values below -10% or above 10% are treated as implausible for this ratio and are not ranked.
  • Charters the regulator has closed, merged or converted are excluded.
  • Each bank charter ranks on its own; holding companies are not combined.

Banks whose quarter was driven by the stock market are left off this list. Since 2018, gains and losses on stocks a bank holds count as income, and at about two dozen banks those paper gains or losses were at least half of pre-tax income for the quarter, which can lift return on assets several-fold (one bank's 7.63% falls to about 2% without them). Each such bank's own page shows its filed figures and explains the gap.

What moves ROA

ROA rises with a wider net interest margin, more fee income or lower operating costs, and falls when the bank has to add to its allowance for credit losses. One-time items move it too: a securities gain or a reserve release can lift a single quarter. Subchapter S banks pay no income tax at the bank level, so their after-tax ROA runs higher than a taxed bank's with the same pre-tax earnings.

Frequently asked questions

Which bank in Ohio has the highest ROA?

Sutton Bank has the highest ROA of the 130 ranked banks headquartered in Ohio, at 4.56% as of September 30, 2026, according to its FFIEC call report. Buckeye State Bank ranks second at 4.14%. The median is 1.18%.

What is the median ROA among ranked US banks?

As of Q3 2026, ROA for the middle half of the 3,622 ranked US banks ran from 0.89% to 1.72%, and the median was 1.30%. Analysts' reference bands run from ≥ 1.50% (strong) to < 0.50% (concern). Compare a bank with peers of the same size and business model rather than with the top of this list. See the Return on Assets reference bands.

How is ROA calculated?

ROA = Annualized Net Income / Average Total Assets. Net income is the bottom line of the income statement, Call Report Schedule RI, item 14. See the Return on Assets glossary entry.

The same ranking in other states

Other Ohio rankings

More profitability rankings

Go past the leaderboard: open any bank for its full financials, 26-year trends, and peer percentiles. Free, no card required.

Start free, no card required

Source: FFIEC call reports for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, refreshed as each quarter's filings are processed. See data updates for the current freshness window. Next update: Q4 2026 Call Reports are due February 1, 2027; we expect them on the platform by mid-February 2027.

Go deeper: ROA vs. ROE for Banks: Profitability Ratios Explained · All bank rankings · Bank metrics glossary · List of all US banks