Skip to main content

Profitability · Ohio

US Banks with Highest Return on Equity (ROE) in Ohio

Ranked among banks headquartered in Ohio. Re-ranked 1-100 within the state from the same national ranking population.

#1 Return on Equity (ROE): NATIONWIDE TRUST COMPANY, FSB — 53.26% . Return on Equity (ROE) is the rate of return banks earn on common shareholders' equity — the standard equity-investor measure of bank profitability.

Ranked: 139 banks with reported data Showing: Top 100 Source: FFIEC call reports (Q1 2026) What is this metric? See the US Banks with … glossary entry Go deeper: ROA vs. ROE for Banks: Profitability Ratios Explained
# Bank HQ US Banks with … Total Assets
1 Nationwide Trust Company, FSB Columbus , OH 53.26% $166.3M
2 Sutton Bank Attica , OH 37.14% $1.68B
3 ST. Henry Bank, the Saint Henry , OH 27.00% $447.9M
4 Citizens National Bank of Bluffton, the Bluffton , OH 23.88% $1.08B
5 Union Savings Bank Cincinnati , OH 22.09% $4.01B
6 Corn City State Bank, the Deshler , OH 21.51% $106.8M
7 Ssb Community Bank Strasburg , OH 21.11% $289.2M
8 Old Fort Banking Company, the Old Fort , OH 20.13% $853.8M
9 First Federal Community Bank, N.A. Dover , OH 19.67% $937.6M
10 Home Loan Savings Bank, the Coshocton , OH 19.60% $383.2M
Full financials, 24-year trends & peer benchmarks on every institution — free. Start free →
11 National Bank of Adams County of West Union, the West Union , OH 18.89% $115.3M
12 Minster Bank Minster , OH 18.62% $814.0M
13 Baltic State Bank, the Baltic , OH 17.84% $123.4M
14 Guardian Savings Bank West Chester , OH 17.84% $1.38B
15 Peoples Bank CO., the Coldwater , OH 17.50% $842.5M
16 Fahey Banking Company, the Marion , OH 16.67% $384.2M
17 JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. Columbus , OH 16.64% $4.02T
18 Park National Bank, the Newark , OH 16.45% $12.93B
19 United Midwest Savings Bank, N.A. De Graff , OH 16.08% $520.6M
20 Farmers & Merchants Bank Miamisburg , OH 16.08% $354.8M
21 Osgood Bank Osgood , OH 15.82% $514.1M
22 Apple Creek Banking Company, the Apple Creek , OH 15.56% $261.2M
23 Unified Bank Martins Ferry , OH 15.33% $852.6M
24 Farmers State Bank West Salem , OH 14.57% $188.1M
25 Commercial and Savings Bank of Millersburg, Ohio, the Millersburg , OH 14.47% $1.27B
26 Main Street Bank CORP. Wooster , OH 13.93% $1.53B
27 First National Bank of Sycamore, the Sycamore , OH 13.79% $239.4M
28 First National Bank in New Bremen New Bremen , OH 13.30% $457.2M
29 Consumers National Bank Minerva , OH 13.25% $1.24B
30 First State Bank Winchester , OH 13.21% $1.19B
31 Greenville National Bank Greenville , OH 13.20% $647.7M
32 Citizens Bank Company, the Beverly , OH 13.18% $329.7M
33 Heartland Bank Whitehall , OH 12.98% $1.97B
34 Union Bank Company, the Columbus Grove , OH 12.76% $1.21B
35 Hocking Valley Bank, the Athens , OH 12.75% $366.9M
36 Woodsfield Savings Bank Woodsfield , OH 12.71% $121.8M
37 National Cooperative Bank, N.A. Hillsboro , OH 12.50% $4.15B
38 Keybank N.A. Cleveland , OH 12.27% $185.98B
39 Waterford Bank, Na Toledo , OH 12.21% $1.72B
40 Citizens National Bank of Woodsfield, the Woodsfield , OH 12.18% $151.7M
41 Vinton County National Bank Mc Arthur , OH 12.16% $1.58B
42 Riverhills Bank Milford , OH 12.11% $343.9M
43 Fort Jennings State Bank, the Fort Jennings , OH 12.09% $278.4M
44 Richwood Banking Company, INC., the Richwood , OH 11.92% $1.27B
45 First Financial Bank Cincinnati , OH 11.88% $22.69B
46 Killbuck Savings Bank Company, the Killbuck , OH 11.88% $941.2M
47 Signature Bank, N.A. Toledo , OH 11.77% $1.28B
48 State Bank and Trust Company, the Defiance , OH 11.75% $1.60B
49 Peoples State Bank New Lexington , OH 11.73% $304.4M
50 U.S. Bank N.A. Cincinnati , OH 11.72% $683.38B
51 Merchants National Bank Hillsboro , OH 11.70% $1.34B
52 Kingston National Bank Kingston , OH 11.59% $582.8M
53 Westfield Bank, FSB Westfield Center , OH 11.57% $2.06B
54 First National Bank of Pandora, the Pandora , OH 11.56% $291.0M
55 Community Savings Caldwell , OH 11.40% $300.7M
56 New Carlisle Federal Savings Bank New Carlisle , OH 11.39% $329.8M
57 Farmers National Bank of Canfield, the Canfield , OH 11.32% $7.22B
58 First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Lakewood Lakewood , OH 11.22% $2.92B
59 Farmers State Bank, the New Madison , OH 11.21% $332.8M
60 Bank of Magnolia Company, the Magnolia , OH 11.19% $109.8M
61 Community Bank, the Zanesville , OH 11.14% $691.0M
62 Portage Community Bank Ravenna , OH 11.03% $555.1M
63 Farmers and Merchants Bank, the Caldwell , OH 10.93% $134.9M
64 Middlefield Banking Company, the Middlefield , OH 10.90% $1.90B
65 Peoples Bank Marietta , OH 10.73% $9.64B
66 Andover Bank, the Andover , OH 10.39% $602.1M
67 First Federal Community Bank of Bucyrus Bucyrus , OH 10.36% $356.2M
68 Croghan Colonial Bank, the Fremont , OH 10.35% $1.35B
69 First National Bank of Mcconnelsville, the Mcconnelsville , OH 10.28% $203.2M
70 Genoa Banking Company, the Genoa , OH 10.27% $731.3M
71 Farmers & Merchants State Bank, the Archbold , OH 10.12% $3.48B
72 Civista Bank Sandusky , OH 10.11% $4.29B
73 Ohio Valley Bank Company, the Gallipolis , OH 10.08% $1.66B
74 Cfbank N.A. Columbus , OH 9.91% $2.14B
75 Settlers Bank Marietta , OH 9.72% $140.2M
76 Ohio State Bank Bexley , OH 9.64% $481.1M
77 North Side Bank and Trust Company, the Cincinnati , OH 9.37% $1.16B
78 First National Bank of Dennison, Ohio, the Dennison , OH 9.24% $271.5M
79 North Valley Bank Zanesville , OH 9.04% $414.6M
80 Huntington National Bank, the Columbus , OH 8.77% $284.14B
81 CenterBank Milford , OH 8.72% $341.3M
82 Somerville Bank Eaton , OH 8.49% $294.3M
83 Peoples Savings Bank, the Urbana , OH 8.48% $185.4M
84 Premier Bank Youngstown , OH 8.20% $8.56B
85 Mechanics Bank Mansfield , OH 8.08% $885.5M
86 Twin Valley Bank, the West Alexandria , OH 7.83% $139.3M
87 Citizens National Bank of Mcconnelsville, the Mcconnelsville , OH 7.79% $106.3M
88 Hamler State Bank, the Hamler , OH 7.74% $125.6M
89 Spring Valley Bank Wyoming , OH 7.72% $115.8M
90 Bank419 Metamora , OH 7.34% $100.2M
91 Farmers Bank and Savings Company, the Pomeroy , OH 7.22% $477.1M
92 Lcnb National Bank Lebanon , OH 7.17% $2.23B
93 The Farmers Savings Bank Spencer , OH 7.05% $293.1M
94 First Federal Savings and Loan Association of Delta Delta , OH 6.94% $247.3M
95 Independence Bank Independence , OH 6.89% $191.4M
96 Hicksville Bank, the Hicksville , OH 6.77% $226.7M
97 Cincinnatus Savings and Loan Company, the Cheviot , OH 6.20% $191.0M
98 Wilmington Savings Bank, the Wilmington , OH 6.20% $265.1M
99 Mercer Savings Bank Celina , OH 6.19% $174.2M
100 First National Bank of Waverly, the Waverly , OH 6.16% $204.4M

More Profitability rankings

Go past the leaderboard — open any bank for its full financials, 24-year trends, and peer percentiles. Free, no card required.

Start free — no card required

All data sourced from the most recent FFIEC call report filings, refreshed each quarter as new filings are processed. This leaderboard excludes banks with total assets under $100,000K to filter out anomalous micro-bank ratios. See /data-updates/ for the current data freshness window.

Explore more: all rankings · glossary · browse all banks